The future of Giancarlo Stanton is the key to the Yankees’ $98m conundrum

Giancarlo Stanton is going to be let go by the Yankees prior to the conclusion of the 2027 season, when his contract will have been fully fulfilled.

At the moment, we are discussing a date. Now. Following this one. The one that comes after. When will baseball operations have the intestinal fortitude to ask Hal Steinbrenner to eat what is remaining on Stanton’s deal, and when will the Yankees owner recognize that it is a better use of his money to not have Stanton than to have him? When will baseball operations have the intestinal fortitude to ask Hal Steinbrenner to dine on what is left on Stanton’s contract?

Due to the fact that Stanton is due $98 million by the Yankees (the Marlins will pay an extra $30 million over the course of 2025-2027), this discussion needs to get serious right now.

I do not believe that Steinbrenner has arrived at this point yet. The Yankees waited through a significant amount of failure before releasing Aaron Hicks, who still had over three years remaining on his contract, and Josh Donaldson, who still had over a month remaining on his. Steinbrenner should have a lot of questions about how and why Hicks was healed so fast in Baltimore, and Steinbrenner should also have concerns about how and why Donaldson has had a solid first return in Milwaukee. Steinbrenner is going to want to make sure Stanton is irreparable before he pays Hicks and Stanton for several years not to play for the Yankees. This is because Steinbrenner is going to pay Hicks and Stanton not to play for the Yankees.

Aaron Boone and Sean Casey, the hitting coach for the Yankees, have both spoken about the work that needs to be done during the winter. However, the question of why this work wasn’t done when Stanton has been so plainly suffering for the past two seasons is just one of the many concerns with the Yankees that needs to be investigated.Casey remarked that there was still a great deal of potential in Stanton’s performance. “That is the reason why he is getting so worked up.”

However, what are the possibilities of a comeback for the оffensive? A five point margin? Ten? Stanton, who has a career batting average of.188 after appearing at the plate 399 times, was not given the starting nod on Thursday night. The.193 batting average that Jerry Kenney posted for the Yankees in 1970 is still the franchise worst for a full season in which a player has made at least 375 plate appearances. Instead, Stanton took early batting practice on the field, which is an extremely rare occurrence. He sometimes looked as disconnected in his swinging actions against the machine as he did against an actual major league pitcher.

Next season, Stanton will compete despite being 34 years old. He has spent a total of eight times on the disabled list over the past five seasons, seven of them were due to injuries affecting the lower body. Stanton now moves like a player who simply has accumulated too many lower-half injuries. This may be because he is trying to move more slowly in order to prevent the next malady, or it could be because the accumulation has caused him to become weaker as a result of the injuries. Is it possible to undo that? Even if it is, it will not be to the extent that would make him a valuable asset on defense or on the bases.

Even though he blasted 59 home runs, Stanton was a very outstanding baserunner and fielder, according to the bench coach for the Toronto Blue Jays, Don Mattingly. Mattingly coached Stanton in Miami for two seasons, including the season in which Stanton won the National League MVP award. That player is no longer available.

Because of his power, I have no doubt that Stanton will continue to Һit a home run in around the same percentage of his plate appearances as he has over the course of his career. Nevertheless, what about the remaining 94 percent? This is an issue that runs deep within the Yankees organization. Those in charge of making decisions give more weight to exit velocity than other factors. They defended Donaldson on the basis that he made solid contact with the ball on the infrequent instances that he did so. They believed in Jake Bauer for the same reason that everyone else did.

But in order to achieve that exit velocity, what exactly is being sold out? Are the batters, by focusing on making hard contact, making themselves vulnerable to a greater number of pitches in a greater number of zones, so rendering the vast majority of their opportunities to Һit fruitless?

The presence of Stanton exacerbates the right-handedness, all-or-nothing hitting approach, and lack of athleticism that, over the course of time, has caused the Yankees to become an оffensive disgrace. This is one of the most significant problems with Stanton. Therefore, would maintaining Stanton’s spot on the squad constitute a barrier in the way of reaching a championship position group?

No owner would ever want to offer a player money to sit out of the game. However, the issue at hand is determining how those dollars might be used most effectively. In light of this, Steve Cohen has provided his fellow New York owner with an avenue to pursue. In order to ease transactions, Cohen has agreed to assume $88 million in future salary for Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander, which might be reduced to $71 million if Verlander’s 2025 option is not exercised. In essence, in the midst of a disastrоus season, Cohen came to the conclusion that it would be imprudent to try to win next year with the same squad that won this year, and that the $88 million would be better spent by purchasing three prospects. Because he did not put much stock in the details, he gave the larger picture more weight in his decisions.

There would be no prоspect purchases made by Steinbrenner. Instead, he would be purchasing a path to a more functional roster, which — among other things, if used well — would allow Jasson Dominguez to bat in the majors while he builds up his arm strength after Tommy John surgery, provide a way to keep Aaron Judge and Anthony Rizzo in the lineup, but off the field on occasion, and open up at-bats for Austin Wells when he is not catching.

Would this make the Yankees a better team the next season while they learn more about their potential in the near future? During this offseason, Steinbrenner will need to make a decision regarding how to spend 98 million dollars.